Lapsed donor re-engagement email template

Two emails to write to people who gave once and went quiet: a warm check-in and a short last note. Copy them, fill in the brackets and send.

Cloud comic with nonprofit volunteers and mascots: Lapsed donors
Lapsed donors

In short: This lapsed donor email template has two emails: a warm check-in that shares one piece of news and asks nothing, and a short last note that offers a choice to stay or step away. Send them a few weeks apart to donors who have not given for a long while. WeGlow Mail also has an automatic re-engagement email for contacts who stopped reading, and it is free up to 250 subscribers.

When to write to a lapsed donor, and to whom

Write to a lapsed donor when they have not given for longer than your supporters usually wait, and start with news, not a request. Two short emails a few weeks apart are enough. WeGlow Mail lets you build that group with a tag or a donor segment and schedule both emails.

StepWhenWho gets it
Check-in with one piece of news, no askWhen a donor has not given for a long time, as you define itLapsed donors you can still reach
Short last note: stay or step awayThree to four weeks laterThose who did not open or answer the first
A real reply from a personWithin two days of any answerEveryone who replies
Tidy the listAfter the last noteContacts who still never open your emails

Decide first what lapsed means for you, for example no gift in the past 24 months. There is no rule, so pick a period that fits how often your supporters usually give.

The lapsed donor re-engagement email template

Replace everything in square brackets. The food bank below is made up. The email thanks, shares one result, asks nothing and makes replying easy.

Example email

From: Northgate Food Bank

It has been a while, [first name]

Here is what your past gifts are still doing.

Dear [first name],

It has been a while since we wrote to you, and we wanted to say thank you. When you gave to Northgate in [year], you helped us open our Saturday pantry.

The pantry is still open. Last month it handed out 240 food parcels, each worth about €15, and a retired baker now brings fresh bread every week.

We are not asking for anything today. We would just like to know whether you still want to hear from us, and what you would like us to write about.

You can answer by replying to this email. It comes to me.

Warm regards,

[sender name], volunteer coordinator at Northgate Food Bank

No button and no ask: the aim is a reply or a click. Use the year of the last gift if you have it in your list. The numbers belong to this made-up food bank.

A short last note: stay or step away

Send this three or four weeks later to people who did not open the first. It is honest, polite and gives a clear choice.

Example email

From: Northgate Food Bank

Shall we keep in touch, [first name]?

One click and we know.

Dear [first name],

We do not want to fill your inbox if you would rather not hear from us. So here is a simple question: do you want to keep receiving our news?

If yes, click the button and we will carry on. If you do nothing, we will stop writing after this email. You can still give or visit at any time.

Thank you for everything you have done for Northgate.

[sender name]

Yes, keep me updated

A button with one clear action. The unsubscribe link at the bottom of the email is always there. People who do not click can be moved to a group you no longer write to.

Why this lapsed donor email works

This lapsed donor email works because it thanks the donor, names the old gift, shares one result and asks for nothing but a reply. The second note gives a clear choice. WeGlow Mail shows opens and clicks, so you can see who answered and who did not.

  • Thanks before anything else: the donor first hears that the gift mattered.
  • The old gift, named: [year] shows you remember, not that a system sent it.
  • One current result: the pantry still open tells them the gift lasted.
  • No ask in the first email: a donor who went quiet is more likely to reply to a question than to an appeal.
  • A clear choice in the second: it respects the reader and tells you who wants to stay.
  • A real reply address: an answer from a person starts a conversation that a campaign does not.

Subject lines to try for lapsed donors

A subject line for a lapsed donor should sound like a person, not a campaign. Keep it short, personal and free of pressure. In WeGlow Mail, Glowie, your writing helper, can draft a few options from your text, and you choose the one that sounds like you.

  • It has been a while, [first name]
  • What your gift in [year] is still doing
  • A quiet thank-you from Northgate
  • Shall we keep in touch, [first name]?
  • One question before we stop writing

For more ideas, read our post on subject lines for nonprofits.

How to send a lapsed donor email with WeGlow Mail

With WeGlow Mail you tag your lapsed donors, write the two emails once and schedule them. There is also an automatic re-engagement email for contacts who stopped reading. Unsubscribes and bounces are skipped automatically, so you only write to people who can still be reached.

  1. 1Build the group. Import your donors from a CSV or Excel file and tag those who have not given for a long time. If you take donations through WeGlow.world, donors are synced into lists and you can use donor segments.
  2. 2Write both emails in the drag-and-drop editor, starting from a ready-made layout. Try it with a free account, no card needed.
  3. 3Send a test to yourself, then schedule the first email and, a few weeks later, the second.
  4. 4Use the automatic re-engagement email for contacts who stopped reading. It is one of the automations, next to the welcome email and manual sequences.
  5. 5Read the report: opens, clicks, unsubscribes and the most-clicked links. Contacts who unsubscribe or bounce are skipped automatically.

When you are ready to ask again, start from the year-end appeal template.

Frequently asked questions

How do I write to lapsed donors?

Start with thanks and one piece of news, ask nothing, and invite a reply. In WeGlow Mail you tag your lapsed donors, write the email from a ready-made layout and send a test to yourself first.

When is a donor lapsed?

There is no fixed rule. Many organisations count a donor as lapsed after one to two years without a gift, but pick a period that fits how often your supporters give. WeGlow Mail lets you tag the group with that rule and write to it separately.

Does WeGlow Mail have an automatic re-engagement email?

Yes. WeGlow Mail has an automatic re-engagement email for contacts who stopped reading, next to the welcome email and manual sequences. For donors who stopped giving, you build the group yourself with a tag or a donor segment.

Should I remove lapsed donors from my list?

After a warm check-in and a last note, you can stop writing to people who never open or answer. In WeGlow Mail, people who unsubscribe or bounce are skipped automatically, and you can move the others to a group you no longer send to.

How much does it cost to email lapsed donors with WeGlow Mail?

WeGlow Mail is free up to 250 subscribers and 500 emails a month, with every feature included, automations too. Above that you pay for the size of your list, from €19 a month for 1,000 subscribers, as shown on the pricing page.

Win back donors who went quiet

Start free and write both emails today. No card needed, up to 250 subscribers, every feature included.

No card needed. The free plan has every feature, up to 250 subscribers. Pricing

Updated: