How to start a nonprofit newsletter, from an empty list to your first send

Six steps for a small team: who you write to, where the first contacts come from, and how the first issue goes out.

Cloud comic with nonprofit volunteers and mascots: Start a nonprofit newsletter
Start a nonprofit newsletter

In short: To start a nonprofit newsletter, decide who it is for and how often you send, gather the contacts who already agreed to hear from you, add a signup form to your website, write a short first issue and send a test before the real send. In WeGlow Mail this fits in an afternoon and is free up to 250 subscribers. Paid plans start at €19 a month for 1,000 subscribers.

The short answer

A nonprofit newsletter starts with three things: a group of readers, a reason to write to them every month, and a tool that sends it. With WeGlow Mail you import the contacts you have, put a signup form on your website and send a first issue of one story and one button.

You do not need a large list to start. Twenty volunteers and forty donors who hear from you every month are worth more than a list of thousands you never write to. The steps below take you from an empty list to a first send.

Step 1: Decide who your nonprofit newsletter is for and how often you send

Write down who will read your newsletter and what they want to know: donors want to see what their gift did, volunteers want dates and tasks, members want news. Then pick a rhythm you can keep. For most small organisations using WeGlow Mail, that is once a month.

ReaderWhat they want to readHow often
DonorsWhat happened with their money, one concrete storyMonthly
VolunteersDates, shifts, practical newsMonthly, or weekly in busy periods
Members and neighboursActivities, results, invitationsMonthly
Partners and sponsorsResults and plansEvery quarter

If the groups want very different things, keep one newsletter for everyone and send a separate short email to volunteers. A rhythm you keep for a year beats an ambitious plan you drop after two issues.

Step 2: Gather the contacts you already have

Your first readers are people who already know you: donors, volunteers, members and people who signed a sheet at an event. Put them in one spreadsheet with an email column, a first name and, if you have it, a language, and import that file into WeGlow Mail as CSV or Excel.

Only add people who agreed to hear from you, or whom you may email on another legal basis. Existing donors are a special case. The guide GDPR and newsletters for nonprofits explains consent and legitimate interest, with links to the official texts.

  • One row per person, one email address per row.
  • Remove duplicates and addresses you know are wrong.
  • Add a column for where the contact came from, such as "event 2026" or "donor". You can turn it into a tag after the import.
  • Keep the original file somewhere safe, as a record of what you imported and when.

Step 3: Set up your sending address

Send from an address on your own domain, such as news@yourcharity.org, not from a free Gmail or Outlook address. Inboxes trust mail more when the domain is verified. In WeGlow Mail you verify your domain with three records (DKIM, SPF and DMARC) that whoever manages your website can add in a few minutes.

Use a name people recognise as the sender name, such as the name of your organisation or a person from the team. If replies come in, read them: a newsletter is also a way for supporters to write back. More on why emails end up in spam is in this blog post.

Inbox providers write down what they expect. Yahoo, for example, asks bulk senders to authenticate their domain and keep spam complaints below 0.3%, according to its sender best practices.

Step 4: Add a signup form before your first issue

Put a signup form on your website before you send the first issue, so new readers can join from day one. WeGlow Mail offers an embedded form, a popup, a slide-in or a hosted page with its own link, and each new subscriber can get an automatic welcome email.

Ask for as little as possible: an email address and a first name are enough. Say what people will get and how often, for example "One email a month with news from the shelter". Then write a short welcome email that says thank you and tells people what to expect.

More places to collect signups, such as events and your donation page, are in the guide how to grow your nonprofit mailing list.

Step 5: Write a short first issue

The first issue does not need to be long. Readers decide in a few seconds whether to keep reading, so give them one thing worth reading. This structure works for most organisations:

  1. 1A subject line that names something concrete: "Pepper found a home" instead of "Newsletter October".
  2. 2One opening sentence that says why you are writing.
  3. 3One story of about 100 words, with a name, a place and what changed.
  4. 4A short round-up of two or three facts from the month.
  5. 5One button with one request: read more, sign up for a shift, or give.
  6. 6A signature from a real person.

If you get stuck on the first lines, Glowie, the writing helper in WeGlow Mail, drafts a newsletter or subject lines from a few notes. You read it and change what you want.

Example email

From: The Community Garden

The garden gate is open again

Hello Sam,

Our volunteers spent Saturday getting the community garden ready for spring. The first seedlings are in, and there is a bench waiting for you.

Come by, meet the team and find out how to join the next planting day.

Visit the garden

Fictional example. Replace the organisation and story with your own.

Step 6: Test, send and read the report

Before the real send, send a test to yourself and open it on your phone. Check the links, the images and the sender name. Then send it or schedule it in WeGlow Mail, and after a few days read the report: opens, clicks and the most-clicked links.

Look at one thing in the report: which link was clicked most. That tells you what your readers care about, and it is a good topic for the next issue. Put the date of the next send in your calendar now.

Common mistakes when you start a newsletter

The usual mistakes at the start are waiting for a big list, adding addresses without permission, writing about the organisation instead of people, using five buttons and skipping the test send. All of them are easy to avoid. In WeGlow Mail you can send a test to yourself before every send.

  • Waiting for a big list. Start with the people you have. A list grows faster once there is a newsletter to sign up for.
  • Adding every address you can find. Business cards and old email threads are not permission to send a newsletter.
  • Writing about the organisation instead of the people. One person's story is read; a list of board decisions is not.
  • Five buttons in one email. One request gets more clicks than five.
  • No test send. A broken link or a missing image is easy to catch on your own phone.
  • Starting weekly and stopping after a month. Pick a rhythm you can keep.

The tools you need to start a nonprofit newsletter

To start a nonprofit newsletter you need a list of contacts, a signup form, an editor that works on phones and a sending service that handles unsubscribes. WeGlow Mail covers all four in one tool, free up to 250 subscribers, and paid plans are on the pricing page.

Plans and prices are on the pricing page.
What you needWhyIn WeGlow Mail
A contact listTo know who gets the emailLists, groups and tags; import from CSV or Excel
A signup formSo new readers can joinEmbedded, popup, slide-in or hosted page
An editorTo write an email that works on a phoneDrag-and-drop blocks, your logo and colours applied automatically
Your own domainSo inboxes trust your mailVerified with DKIM, SPF and DMARC
Unsubscribe handlingRequired, and keeps your list cleanUnsubscribes and bounces skipped automatically
A reportTo see what was readOpens, clicks and most-clicked links

Frequently asked questions

How do I start a newsletter for my nonprofit?

Decide who it is for and how often you send, import the contacts who agreed to hear from you, add a signup form and write a short first issue with one story and one button. In WeGlow Mail you can do all of this in one afternoon, free up to 250 subscribers.

How many subscribers do I need to start a newsletter?

None. You can start with the volunteers and donors you already have and grow from there. WeGlow Mail is free up to 250 subscribers, so a small list costs nothing.

How often should a nonprofit send a newsletter?

Once a month works for most small organisations: often enough to be remembered, rare enough to keep up. In WeGlow Mail you can schedule each issue in advance, so it goes out on the same day every month.

What should be in the first nonprofit newsletter?

One short story with a name and a result, two or three facts from the month and one button with one request. WeGlow Mail has ready-made layouts for this, and Glowie, the writing helper, can draft the first version.

Is there a free newsletter tool for nonprofits?

Yes. WeGlow Mail is free for nonprofits up to 250 subscribers and 500 emails a month, with every feature included. Above that you pay for the size of your list, from €19 a month for 1,000 subscribers and €29 for 2,500.

Send your first newsletter this month

Create a free account and build your first issue. No card needed: up to 250 subscribers, every feature, your first send today.

No card needed. The free plan has every feature, up to 250 subscribers. Pricing

Updated: