
In short: To win back lapsed donors by email, send three short emails over about three weeks: a thank-you with an update, a story, and a clear ask. Build the group first and keep it to people you have the right to email. WeGlow Mail has groups and tags, scheduling and an automatic re-engagement email for contacts who stopped reading. Free up to 250 subscribers.
Who counts as a lapsed donor
A lapsed donor is someone who gave before but has not given for a while. There is no official definition, so as a rule of thumb many organisations use a gift older than 12 to 18 months, adjusted to how often your supporters normally give. WeGlow Mail lets you keep that group separate.
This is our rule of thumb, not a standard. If your donors give once a year at year-end, 12 months without a gift is normal and 18 months is the point to act. If you run a monthly campaign, 6 months of silence may already mean something. Pick a rule, write it down and use the same one every time.
Lapsed is not the same as unsubscribed. Someone who unsubscribed told you to stop, so they are not part of this group.
How to build the group in WeGlow Mail
Build one clear group of lapsed donors, with a tag that says why they are in it. In WeGlow Mail you use groups and tags, and you can import from CSV or Excel. If your organisation is connected to WeGlow.world, donors are synced into lists and donor segments are available.
- 1Export your donors with their last gift date from your own records, or from WeGlow.world if you are connected.
- 2Keep the ones whose last gift is older than your rule of thumb.
- 3Remove anyone who unsubscribed or whose address bounced.
- 4Import the file in WeGlow Mail and tag the group, for example lapsed donors.
- 5Keep a separate group for recent donors. They get a different email.
Bounced and unsubscribed addresses are skipped automatically in WeGlow Mail, but a clean file saves you checking later.
The three-step win-back sequence
Send three short emails over about three weeks: a thank-you with an update on day 1, a story around day 8 and a clear ask around day 15. Only the third email asks for a gift. In WeGlow Mail you write all three in one sitting and schedule them for later.
| Step | When | What it does | One action |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Thank-you and update | Day 1 | Thanks them for what they gave and shows what it made possible | Read the update |
| 2. A story | About day 8 | One person, animal or place that shows the work, with a photo | Read the story |
| 3. A clear ask | About day 15 | Asks for one specific gift and says what it pays for | Give |
Write each email in under 150 words with one button, in the same voice as your usual newsletter. The first email asks for nothing. That is what makes the third one feel fair.
What to write in each email
Email one thanks them by name and says what happened since their last gift. Here is a sample from a fictional organisation, which you can adapt. Our thank-you email template has more wording.
From: Harbour Animal Rescue
What your last gift made possible
A short update, and a thank-you.
Hi Sam,
Some time ago you supported Harbour Animal Rescue. We never said a proper thank-you, so here it is.
Since then, the new quiet room has opened, and nine cats left it for a home of their own.
No ask today. We just wanted you to know where your gift went.
See the updateA fictional example. Figures inside a sample email are made up.
Email two tells one story, with a name and a photo, and ends with a link to read more. Email three is the ask: one amount or one need, what it pays for, and a single Give button. Add a line saying they can unsubscribe at any time.
Consent: check before you write
A donor who gave in the past has not automatically agreed to receive newsletters. Check where each address came from and what the person agreed to. Our GDPR guide for nonprofit newsletters links to the official texts and explains consent and legitimate interest. That is general information, not legal advice.
If you are unsure about part of your list, leave that part out of this sequence, or ask for consent in a short, honest email first.
When to stop writing to people
Stop after the third email if someone has not opened, clicked or given. Keep writing to people who click, even without giving. WeGlow Mail has an automatic re-engagement email for contacts who stopped reading, and it skips unsubscribed addresses. Persistent silence is a reason to rest the contact, not to email harder.
- No clicks after three emails: move them to a quiet group and send them only your yearly update.
- A click but no gift: keep them on your normal newsletter.
- A gift: thank them within days and move them back to the donors group.
- An unsubscribe or a complaint: stop at once.
Writing to people who no longer read hurts your reputation with inbox providers, as the article on why emails land in spam explains. A smaller, engaged list reaches more inboxes. Inbox providers set limits too: Yahoo asks bulk senders to keep spam complaints below 0.3% and to honour an unsubscribe within 2 days, according to its sender best practices.
Schedule it and read the results
Write the three emails in one sitting, send a test of each to yourself and schedule them for later in WeGlow Mail. Then read the report after each send: clicks and the most-clicked links tell you whether the story or the ask worked. Opens are less reliable, so give them less weight.
Check what each number means in our guide to nonprofit email metrics. Count the gifts that arrive in the days after email three, and compare with the size of the group. That number is your result, and next year's rule of thumb.
Frequently asked questions
How long before a donor counts as lapsed?
There is no official answer. A common rule of thumb is a last gift older than 12 to 18 months, adjusted to your usual giving rhythm. In WeGlow Mail you can keep these donors in their own group with a tag.
How many emails should I send to win back lapsed donors?
Three short emails over about three weeks: a thank-you and update, a story, and a clear ask. Then stop if there is no response. WeGlow Mail lets you schedule all three in advance.
Can I email donors who gave years ago?
It depends on what they agreed to and where their address came from. Giving a gift is not the same as agreeing to a newsletter, so read the guide on GDPR first. WeGlow Mail skips unsubscribed addresses, but the legal basis stays your organisation's responsibility.
Should I ask for a donation in the first win-back email?
No. Start with a thank-you and an update, and keep the ask for the third email. WeGlow Mail's thank-you wording and reports help you see which email people clicked.
What does WeGlow Mail do for contacts who stopped reading?
WeGlow Mail has an automatic re-engagement email for contacts who stopped reading. If your organisation is connected to WeGlow.world, donors are synced into lists, and donor segments are available. You decide who to keep writing to.
Write your three emails
Create a free account, import your lapsed donors and schedule the sequence. No card needed: every feature, up to 250 subscribers.
No card needed. The free plan has every feature, up to 250 subscribers. Pricing
Updated: