
In short: For nonprofit email metrics, trust clicks, unsubscribes and what people do after the email, such as a donation or a sign-up. Treat opens with care: Apple Mail loads email content in the background, so opens can be counted when nobody read the message. WeGlow Mail reports opens, clicks, unsubscribes and your most-clicked links in plain words. Only opens and clicks are tracked. Free up to 250 subscribers.
What to measure and what to ignore
Measure what a person chose to do: click a link, unsubscribe, donate, sign up. Ignore single numbers and anything you cannot act on. WeGlow Mail reports opens, clicks, unsubscribes and your most-clicked links, and tracks only opens and clicks, so the report stays small enough to read in five minutes.
A small team does not need a dashboard full of charts. You need to know three things after each send: did people read it, did they act, and did anyone leave. The rest of this guide goes through the numbers in that order.
Why open rates mislead
An open is counted when a tiny image in the email loads. Since Apple's Mail Privacy Protection, Apple Mail can load that image in the background whether or not the person opens the message. Opens can therefore be too high, so treat them as a rough signal and never as proof of reading.
Apple explains on its page about Mail Privacy Protection that Mail downloads remote content in the background by default, whether or not you open the email, and routes it through relays so senders cannot see your IP address. Without that protection, senders could learn when and how often an email was opened. The effect on a sender is that opens from Apple Mail users can no longer be taken at face value.
What to do instead: compare opens only between your own sends, over time, and let clicks and replies decide what worked. A subject line that gets more opens has not been proven better. A subject line that gets more clicks has.
Clicks, unsubscribes and bounces
After each send, look at clicks and the most-clicked links first, then at unsubscribes, bounces and spam complaints. Clicks show what people chose to do. Google and Yahoo ask bulk senders to keep complaints below 0.3%, and Yahoo wants an unsubscribe honoured within 2 days. WeGlow Mail skips bounced and unsubscribed addresses automatically.
| Metric | What it tells you | What to do with it |
|---|---|---|
| Clicks | Someone chose to act on something in your email | Compare sends: which link, which subject, which story |
| Most-clicked links | What your supporters care about | Move the most-clicked topic higher in the next email |
| Unsubscribes | The email or the frequency did not fit | Watch for a jump after one send, then reread that email |
| Bounces | The address does not work | Never retry them. WeGlow Mail skips bounced addresses automatically |
| Spam complaints | People pressed spam instead of unsubscribing | Keep them very low: Google says below 0.30%, Yahoo below 0.3% |
The complaint limits come from Google's sender guidelines and Yahoo's sender best practices, read on 12 November 2026. They apply to bulk senders, but they show how seriously inbox providers take complaints. An easy unsubscribe link is the best protection, and our guide to DKIM, SPF and DMARC covers the technical side.
Donations and sign-ups per email: the number that matters
The best measure of a nonprofit email is what happened after it: gifts, sign-ups, volunteers who said yes. Count them on your own donation or sign-up page for the days after a send and compare. WeGlow Mail shows the clicks that lead there, and the donor sync with WeGlow.world connects the donors.
A simple habit: write down, for each send, the date, the one action you asked for, and how many people took it in the next three days. After a few months you will see which kind of email brings people in. Keep the ask single and clear, as in our guide to your first newsletter.
Be honest about the limits. A gift made a week later, or after a conversation, is hard to link to one email. Treat the count as a direction, not an accounting.
Trends beat single numbers
One email with a low click count says little. A summer send is quieter than a year-end appeal, and a short list moves a lot with a few people. Look at the last five or six sends side by side, and ask whether clicks and unsubscribes are rising, falling or flat.
Be careful with benchmarks too. We do not quote average rates here, because the figures differ by source, sector and how opens are counted. If you want a comparison, use your own earlier emails.
How to read your WeGlow Mail reports
WeGlow Mail reports opens, clicks, unsubscribes and the most-clicked links of each email, explained in plain words. Read clicks and the most-clicked links first, then unsubscribes, and look at opens last. Only opens and clicks are tracked, and bounced or unsubscribed addresses are skipped automatically.
- 1Open the report of your latest newsletter.
- 2Start with the most-clicked links: this is what your supporters wanted.
- 3Check the clicks against your one ask. Did the main button get most of them?
- 4Look at unsubscribes. A few after a send is normal. A jump is a reason to reread that email.
- 5Glance at opens last, with the Apple Mail caveat in mind.
- 6Write one line in your own notes: what you will do differently next time.
Keeping your list clean also keeps the numbers honest. See how in our guide to growing your mailing list.
A five minute routine after every send
Wait three days, open the report, note the most-clicked link and the number of unsubscribes, and count the gifts or sign-ups. Do the same after each send and keep the notes in one place. After six sends you have your own benchmark. If your readers are slipping away, the next step is a win-back sequence for lapsed donors.
Frequently asked questions
Are email open rates still reliable?
Only partly. Apple says Mail Privacy Protection downloads remote content in the background by default, whether or not the email is opened, so opens can be overcounted. WeGlow Mail still reports opens, but use clicks and what people do afterwards as the real signal.
What is a good click rate for a nonprofit newsletter?
There is no single honest number, because it depends on your list, your sector and how the click is counted. The most useful comparison is your own last five sends. WeGlow Mail shows clicks and your most-clicked links so you can compare send to send.
How many unsubscribes are normal?
A few after each send is normal. Look for a sudden jump after one email, then reread it and check the frequency. WeGlow Mail reports unsubscribes per email and skips unsubscribed addresses automatically.
Does WeGlow Mail track anything besides opens and clicks?
No. WeGlow Mail tracks only opens and clicks, and the report shows opens, clicks, unsubscribes and the most-clicked links in plain words. Bounced and unsubscribed addresses are skipped automatically.
How do I know if a newsletter raised donations?
Count the gifts or sign-ups on your own page in the days after a send, and compare with the most-clicked link in the report. It shows a direction rather than exact proof. With WeGlow Mail you can also sync donors from WeGlow.world into your lists when your organisation is connected.
Read your first report
Create a free account, send your first newsletter and see the report in plain words. No card needed: every feature, up to 250 subscribers.
No card needed. The free plan has every feature, up to 250 subscribers. Pricing
Apple's page on Mail Privacy Protection, Google's email sender guidelines and Yahoo's sender best practices, read on 12 November 2026. Updated: